@walter-erquinigo found the the [PR with testing and a fix for
DebugInfoD](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/98344) caused an
issue when working with stripped binaries.
The issue is that when you're working with split-dwarf, there are *3*
possible files: The stripped binary the user is debugging, the
"only-keep-debug" *or* unstripped binary, plus the `.dwp` file. The
debuginfod plugin should provide the unstripped/OKD binary. However, if
the debuginfod plugin fails, the default symbol locator plugin will just
return the stripped binary, which doesn't help. So, to address that, the
SymbolVendorELF code checks to see if the SymbolLocator's
ExecutableObjectFile request returned the same file, and bails if that's
the case. You can see the specific diff as the second commit in the PR.
I'm investigating adding a test: I can't quite get a simple repro, and
I'm unwilling to make any additional changes to Makefile.rules to this
diff, for Pavlovian reasons.
This reverts commit 2fa1220a37a3f55b76a29803d8333b3a3937d53a.
This reverts commit b9496a74eb4029629ca2e440c5441614e766f773.
The patch #98344 causes a crash in LLDB when parsing some files like `numpy.libs/libgfortran-daac5196.so.5.0.0` on graviton (you can download it in https://drive.google.com/file/d/12ygLjJwWpzdYsrzBPp1JGiFHxcgM0-XY/view?usp=drive_link if you want to troubleshoot yourself).
The assert that is hit is the following:
```
llvm-project/lldb/source/Plugins/ObjectFile/ELF/ObjectFileELF.cpp:2452: std::pair<unsigned int, std::map<long unsigned int, lldb_private::AddressClass> > ObjectFileELF::ParseSymbolTable(lldb_private::Symtab*, lldb::user_id_t, lldb_private::Section*): Assertion `strtab->GetObjectFile() == this' failed.
[383588:383636:20240716,025305.572639:ERROR crashpad_client_linux.cc:780] Crashpad isn't enabled
```
This object file doesn't have apparently a strings table but LLDB still tries to process it due to the code that is being reverted.
This is all the tests and fixes I've had percolating since my first
attempt at this in January. After 6 months of trying, I've given up on
adding the ability to test DWP files in LLDB API tests. I've left both
the tests (disabled) and the changes to Makefile.rules in place, in the
hopes that someone who can configure the build bots will be able to
enable the tests once a non-borked dwp tool is widely available.
Other than disabling the DWP tests, this continues to be the same diff
that I've tried to land and
[not](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/90622)
[revert](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/87676)
[five](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/86812)
[times](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/85693)
[before](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/96802). There are a
couple of fixes that the testing exposed, and I've abandoned the DWP
tests because I want to get those fixes finally upstreamed, as without
them DebugInfoD is less useful.
Reverts llvm/llvm-project#96802
Attempt #5 fails. It's been 6 months. I despise Makefile.rules and have
no ability to even *detect* these failures without _landing_ a diff. In
the mean time, we have no testing for DWP files at all (and a regression
that was introduced, that I fix with this diff) so I'm going to just
remove some of the tests and try to land it again, but with less testing
I guess.
This is the same diff I've put up at many times before. I've been trying
to add some brand new functionality to the LLDB test infrastucture
(create split-dwarf files!), and we all know that no good deed goes
unpunished. The last attempt was reverted because it didn't work on the
Fuchsia build.
There are no code differences between this and
[the](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/90622)
[previous](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/87676)
[four](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/86812)
[diffs](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/85693) landed &
reverted (due to testing infra failures). The only change in this one is
the way `dwp` is being identified in `Makefile.rules`.
Thanks to @petrhosek for helping me figure out how the fuchsia builders
are configured. I now prefer to use llvm-dwp and fall back to gnu's dwp
if the former isn't found. Hopefully this will work everywhere it needs
to.
Here we go with attempt number five. Again, no changes to the LLDB code
diff, which has been reviewed several times.
For the tests, I added a `@skipIfCurlSupportMissing` annotation so that
the Debuginfod mocked server stuff won't run, and I also disabled
non-Linux/FreeBSD hosts altogether, as they fail for platform reasons on
macOS and Windows. In addition, I updated the process for extracting the
GNU BuildID to no create a target, per some feedback on the previous
diff.
For reference, previous PR's (landed, backed out after the fact for
various reasons) #90622, #87676, #86812, #85693
---------
Co-authored-by: Kevin Frei <freik@meta.com>
And "LLDB Debuginfod tests and a fix or two (#90622)".
f8fedfb6802173372ec923f99f31d4af810fbcb0 /
2d4acb086541577ac6ab3a140b9ceb9659ce7094
As it has caused a test failure on 32 bit Arm:
https://lab.llvm.org/buildbot/#/builders/17/builds/52580
Expr/TestStringLiteralExpr.test. The follow up did fix
lang/c/shared_lib_stripped_symbols/TestSharedLibStrippedSymbols.py
but not the other failure.
I'm taking yet another swing at getting these tests going, on the
hypothesis that the problems with buildbots & whatnot are because
they're not configured with CURL support, which I've confirmed would
cause the previous tests to fail. (I have no access to an ARM64 linux
system, but I did repro the failure on MacOS configured without CURL
support)
So, the only difference between this diff and
[previous](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/85693)
[diffs](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/87676) that have
already been approved is that I've added a condition to the tests to
only run if Debuginfod capabilities should be built into the binary. I
had done this for these tests when they were [Shell
tests](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/79181) and not API
tests, but I couldn't find a direct analog in any API test, so I used
the "plugins" model used by the intel-pt tests as well.
---------
Co-authored-by: Kevin Frei <freik@meta.com>
This reverts commit d6713ad80d6907210c629f22babaf12177fa329c.
This changed was reverted because of greendragon failures such
as
Unresolved Tests (2):
lldb-api :: debuginfod/Normal/TestDebuginfod.py
lldb-api :: debuginfod/SplitDWARF/TestDebuginfodDWP.py
I believe I've got the tests properly configured to only run on Linux
x86(_64), as I don't have a Linux AArch64/Arm device to diagnose what's
going wrong with the tests (I suspect there's some issue with generating
`.note.gnu.build-id` sections...)
The actual code fixes have now been reviewed 3 times:
https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/79181 (moved shell tests to
API tests), https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/85693 (Changed
some of the testing infra), and
https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/86812 (didn't get the tests
configured quite right). The Debuginfod integration for symbol
acquisition in LLDB now works with the `executable` and `debuginfo`
Debuginfod network requests working properly for normal, `objcopy
--only-keep-debug` stripped, split-dwarf, and `objcopy
--only-keep-debug` stripped *plus* split-dwarf symbols/binaries.
The reasons for the multiple attempts have been tests on platforms I
don't have access to (Linux AArch64/Arm + MacOS x86_64). I believe I've
got the tests properly disabled for everything except for Linux x86(_64)
now. I've built & tested on MacOS AArch64 and Linux x86_64.
---------
Co-authored-by: Kevin Frei <freik@meta.com>
The previous diff (and it's subsequent fix) were reverted as the tests
didn't work properly on the AArch64 & ARM LLDB buildbots. I made a
couple more minor changes to tests (from @clayborg's feedback) and
disabled them for non Linux-x86(_64) builds, as I don't have the ability
do anything about an ARM64 Linux failure. If I had to guess, I'd say the
toolchain on the buildbots isn't respecting the `-Wl,--build-id` flag.
Maybe, one day, when I have a Linux AArch64 system I'll dig in to it.
From the reverted PR:
I've migrated the tests in my
https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/79181 from shell to API (at
@JDevlieghere's suggestion) and addressed a couple issues that were
exposed during testing.
The tests first test the "normal" situation (no DebugInfoD involvement,
just normal debug files sitting around), then the "no debug info"
situation (to make sure the test is seeing failure properly), then it
tests to validate that when DebugInfoD returns the symbols, things work
properly. This is duplicated for DWP/split-dwarf scenarios.
---------
Co-authored-by: Kevin Frei <freik@meta.com>
Finally getting back to Debuginfod tests:
I've migrated the tests in my [earlier
PR](https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/79181) from shell to API
(at @JDevlieghere's suggestion) and addressed a couple issues that came
about during testing.
The tests first test the "normal" situation (no DebugInfoD involvement,
just normal debug files sitting around), then the "no debug info"
situation (to make sure the test is seeing failure properly), then it
tests to validate that when Debuginfod returns the symbols, things work
properly. This is duplicated for DWP/split-dwarf scenarios.
---------
Co-authored-by: Kevin Frei <freik@meta.com>
